Is there any other profession that would tolerate the high percentage of its members who are so underemployed as contingent workers? We need to understand that college teaching, like any other profession, thrives when it can assure its members some degree of security and a decent livelihood. College teaching no longer does that. Most importantly, conditions are such that those teachers dedicated to teaching in the
...more »
Is there any other profession that would tolerate the high percentage of its members who are so underemployed as contingent workers? We need to understand that college teaching, like any other profession, thrives when it can assure its members some degree of security and a decent livelihood. College teaching no longer does that. Most importantly, conditions are such that those teachers dedicated to teaching in the first year or two of college, and who have acquired some good experience, consistently have such experience, and the expertise accompanying it, devalued. For a school to be a school, it needs to create a culture of teaching and learning that is created by staff who are invested, over time, in that school, who understand the specific challenges of its students at a particular location, and who, because they are not contingent workers, continue to be invested,in both their students and the institution they attend. The ongoing work of building such a culture and such a commun ity is insulted and undermined by current hiring practices and working conditions. Again, while we bemoan the low graduation rate, we do nothing to reward and develop those teachers who have dedicated themselves to teaching first-year and other introductory courses so crucial for developing the sort of higher literacy we want students to develop. In short, we talk the talk but don't walk the walk, so until such teachers receive the security and the working conditions needed to shape real communities where students can truly flourish, I believe there's sufficient reason to be cynical about all this hand wringing over the high drop-out rate of so many students. Check out the graduation rates which are most respectable; I suspect they are so because of institutions that have not yielded to the exploiting practices of so much academic labor. (And please, please, don't hand me that old saw about how "valuable" adjuncts are because "they bring real world experience to the classroom." No one disputes that. However, to say that justifies a steady increase in the percentage of part-time teachers, i.e., the adjunctification of the professoriate, is an absurd stretch. So I would implore those who are sympathetic to my position not to get caught in the trap many administrators like to spring when they turn us into unfair critics of those who bring professional experience into the classroom.)
« less
full details »